Do not let the cover deceive you like it did me. This is not a middle grade graphic novel. I also think that the author took a fascinating premise brimming with potential and squandered it. The story throws readers into the deep end at the start – a common technique – but never back sup and explains anything. The little that side characters reveal comes in drips and drabs easily missed by the reader. At times I could see an
excellent story shining through only to then see that spark snuffed out by an or jump in time or location. I will definitely not add this to my classroom shelves.
My students seem to gravitate towards these types of contemporary stories. I found this one to be yet another excellent example of this category. I will definitely read the sequels as well as add this to the classroom shelves.
This story takes place a little prior to the events of the first book of the series. While I, as a fan of the original series, enjoyed this entry, those who have not read the original books would likely miss many of the crucial points as this graphic novel cannot stand on its own. I may purchase it to complete my own collection but would not add it to my classroom shelves.
Based on the cover, I expected an older leaning graphic novel that probably would not work for a middle school classroom. I was half right. The graphic novel features high school age characters, which I did not expect, and leans far more towards horror than fantasy. Perhaps if the author had made clear the identity of the main character (it seems to be one character but then that character gets taken out of the narrative and
the reader then realizes that the main character was a different person), the book might have stood a chance with me. In the end, however, with not a single likable character, I doubt it. I will nto add this one to any shelf.
I loved returning to these characters and I especially appreciated how Chantler took the story in a different direction, a direction that gave the squire the opportunity to learn and grow. Although it does not look like Chantler has any sequels planned, I hope that more will come in the future. I will definitely add this sequel to my classroom shelves.
Escabasse did an excellent job in this sequel. The main character has settled into her new life with her new family and newly discovered magical powers. Then a new kid throws a wrench in her friendships and she has to learn how to be a good friend deal with yet more change. I love how Escabasse incorporated the friendship drama with magical dilemma. This one will join the first in the series on my classroom shelves.
Leave a Reply