2026 Goodreads Choice Awards Project – Part 1

It’s that time again!

Once again, my pre-drop stats are a bit of a mixed bag.

Pre-Drop Stats

It’s clear that I am reading far less young adult fantasy (and other genres as well). I think part of that comes from the fact that I have cancelled several subscriptions and do not prefer heavy romance in my fantasy. I am considering dropping this category from my Goodreads Choice Awards in the future.

All of the new release reading throughout the year paid off! Of the books remaining, I will read all but 1 of them. I sincerely hoped that Goodreads would not put the 18th book in a series on the list but alas. They did. I also had a chance to read Witch Queen Rising earlier in the year but returned the book because the stats didn’t indicate it would be on the list.

The Reviews Begin

I definitely should have read this long before the nominees were dropped. I’ve had it checked out a few times over the year, but just never made it a priority. Once I got back into the story, something the author makes easy, I stayed engaged for the entire novel and was even able to suspend this belief about some aspects of the romantic relationship. Even though I think that I may be leaving my days of reading YA fantasy behind, this book stood out in a positive way. It’s not the best that I have ever read, but it’s one of the better ones that I have read in 2026.

This book should have been nominated in the regular YA fiction section. The first book in this interconnected series which I read the year it was published for the Goodreads Choice Awards had, in my opinion, enough of a slightly fantastical nature to somewhat justify its inclusion in this category. This book, however, did not. The author includes only a smidgen of magical realism that drives a good bit of the plot, but that bit itself makes up a small fraction of the plot events and character choices. Surprisingly, I enjoyed this entry more than the first but not enough to voluntarily pick up more works by this author.

It’s a shame that it took the Goodreads Choice Awards release for me to realize that this author had released another book. Her debut novel is one of the most powerful books that I have ever read. Out of all of the books that I had not read on the YA fantasy list, I was most excited to read this one. This author has an incredible way of building a window to person‘s life, a life marked by grief, but also a life that holds so much more. She also does the building with magical realism that feels believable and necessary. As opposed to the other magical realism book on the list, I definitely think that this book belongs in this category. This book is different in many ways than as long As Long as the Lemon Trees Grow since it takes place in the United States and not in the Syrian war zone. Some readers may enter this book, expecting the same sort of trauma and be put off by the vulnerabilities revealed. I did expect a different setting at first, but once I figured out where we were, I settled into the narrative and sat back in awe of what she has crafted. The main character transfers to a rich private school for her senior year, her father’s effort to make her life better in the wake of her mother/his wife’s tragic passing. At the school, she faces the unfortunate expected racism because she wears the hijab and is Muslim and Syrian. A lot of the actions taken by the white privileged characters, are similar to another bookI read recently, but unlike that book which frustrated me immensely because of the lack of pushback, this book had that in spades. I still prefer this authors debut, but I will most definitely pick up anything she writes and will purchase this book as soon as I possibly can. 

This book follows a surprisingly common trend of divine battles/replacement contests that I’ve read recently. I appreciate Marie Lou’s writing, but ultimately this book fell a little flat. I found the world that she set up intriguing and more believable than the world in A Stage Set for Villains. That being said, the pivotal relationship between the main character and her reported love interest hinged on a lot of telling not showing. The more that I thought about that relationship, the more that I realized that the strong friendship between the main character and another ultimately pivotal player, also involved way too much telling rather than showing, since the bonding between the characters took place long before the narrative began, and kept getting reference to without any exhibits of it until the characters were in life and depth situations. As a character driven reader, this left the book feeling ultimately on satisfying, but not deeply so. 

I mistakenly assumed that this was the same book as Thistlemarsh since they are both adult fantasy novels that came up this year and have one word titles. Having not yet read the other one, I do not know if there are any other similarities. Back to this book. The author built an intriguing world based on our own world, but with a fantastical twist. I appreciated how she built a lot of of the nuances between different countries and types of people, things that felt natural without seeming like direct copies from reality with names changed. I also found the introduction of the fantastical aspect intriguing since this aspect does not become apparent until partway through the book. It always takes a lot for me to be swayed in terms of believing a romantic pairing, since I am fairly skeptical in that matter, but this author did a pretty good job. I definitely will continue in this series. 

When I saw this book on the Goodreads Choice Awards list, I wondered what I would eventually think of it, and if it would end up as a DNF. I have heard some reviews of this book along with the authors first book and from those reviews figured that his writing is likely not my cup of tea. As I started reading, I was not initially turned off. I found the premise intriguing, intriguing enough to keep reading. Around the 25% mark things start to get really weird. I read a little bit after things started to get weird but when they stayed weird, realized that this is definitely not the book for me. Thus, I proved my own predictions right and DNF’d the book. This may be for some people, but it was not for me.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *